About the Theory

Criticism and the Author’s Responses

Author: Sergey V. GoltsovText by the author of the theory

The history of science shows that new concepts are rarely accepted at once. Between the emergence of an idea and its recognition there is often a period of criticism, doubt and rethinking. Phenotypic Dermatology was no exception.

Over the years of working on the theory, I have received a number of reviews and remarks. I consider them an important part of its development. Criticism makes it possible to see not only the weaknesses of a new model but also the limits of how it is perceived within the existing scientific paradigm. Below are several characteristic remarks.

Below are excerpts from three reviews (the scans were published by the author) and the author’s responses. The scans are in Russian; each is followed by an English translation of the excerpt. The short headings of the remarks were added by the site editors.

Remark 1. Relevance of the topic

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 1; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: Review No. 1. “The role of phenotypic diversity of skin cells in the practice of a dermatologist”. 1. Relevance of the research topic: there is no justification for the need to develop and introduce a new approach to diagnosing the skin state and skin diseases.

The author’s response. In my view, this remark concerns not so much the results of the study as the question of whether it is necessary to move from a symptom-oriented description to phenotypic analysis. It is precisely this transition that is the subject of the theory.

Remark 2. Aim of the study

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 2; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: 2. Aim of the study: “To substantiate the use of flow cytometry for the quantitative and functional assessment of the phenotypic diversity of human skin cells in the diagnostic and research practice of a dermatologist, and to evaluate its effectiveness.” Flow cytometry has long been known; “substantiating the use of the method” cannot be an aim!

The author’s response. In this case, the point is not to substantiate flow cytometry as such. The method is used as a tool for moving to a new level of analysis — the study of the phenotypic states of skin cells.

Remark 3. Notions and concepts

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 3; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: 6. In the description of the calculations in Chapter 5, it is completely unclear to the reader what the author means by “concepts”, and what, from the point of view of a dermatologist (immunologist), is meant by “a technology that operates with concepts on the basis of rigorous mathematical methods and makes it possible to derive logically consistent consequences from statements and assumptions obtained empirically” (quotation). The formation of “phenomenologies A, B, C” is also unclear.

The author’s response. This kind of remark seems particularly interesting, since it points to a difference in conceptual frameworks. The theory proposes to consider the skin not as a set of symptoms or of fixed cell subpopulations, but as a dynamic system of phenotypes.

Remark 4. Cell subpopulations

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 4; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: Quotation: “Each subpopulation involves a specific proportion of cells of each type with their different functions. All theoretically conceivable subpopulations are admissible, since there are no restrictions on their diversity, or such restrictions are unknown”… This statement contradicts the classical definition of a subpopulation as a set of cells that have a precisely defined set of CD markers (Th4, Th8, Th17, NK, TNK and other subpopulations) and have functions of the same type.

The author’s response. Here one of the key differences between the traditional and the phenotypic approaches becomes apparent. While the classical model emphasizes the cell’s belonging to a particular population, the phenotypic approach considers the functional state of the cell and its variability.

Remark 5. Presentation of the work

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 5; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: Review No. 2. General conclusion on the work of S. V. Goltsov based on the dissertation abstract “The role of phenotypic diversity of skin cells in the practice of a dermatologist”. 1. The presentation of the dissertation abstract does not conform to the format accepted for specialty 14.01.10.

The author’s response. This remark concerns the form in which the material is presented, not its content. Formatting is certainly important for the academic procedure, but in itself it does not make it possible to judge whether a scientific concept is sound or unsound.

Remark 6. Title of the work

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 6; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: 2. The title of the dissertation does not reflect the predominantly experimental nature of the work and its immunological component.

The author’s response. This remark actually reflects a difference in understanding the aim of the study. To the reviewer, the work appears to be primarily experimental. For the author, the experiment is a tool for solving a broader problem — forming a new model for describing the skin state at the phenotypic level.

Remark 7. Conceptual methods

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 7; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: …and the motives for turning to conceptual methods are given, which opens up prospects for the development of dermatology (???).

The author’s response. “The author turns to conceptual methods...” is, in my view, the most interesting part of the whole review. Moreover, the context makes it clear that this is regarded as a shortcoming rather than otherwise.

This remark touches on one of the fundamental questions of the development of science. Experiment makes it possible to obtain new data, but data by themselves do not yet constitute a theory. Forming a new level of description requires conceptualization — building a system of notions capable of explaining the observed phenomena and linking individual facts into a single model. This is exactly the task that Phenotypic Dermatology set itself.

Remark 8. Formulation of the conclusions

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 8; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: The formulation of the conclusions does not make it possible to assess whether they correspond to the research materials; some of them are declarative.

The author’s response. This remark deserves special attention. A new theory always formulates statements that go beyond individual experiments. In this sense, theoretical conclusions may indeed be perceived as excessively broad relative to specific data. However, it is precisely the ability to generalize results and to form new explanatory models that distinguishes a theory from a collection of experimental observations.

What seemed most important to me in the second review, if I were to single out one idea, is this: the first reviewer argued with the very possibility of a new model; the second reviewer keeps trying to bring the work back from the level of theory to the level of experiment. And this is a very interesting difference.

In essence, the whole review can be reduced to one phrase: “Show the experiment and do not go beyond it.” Phenotypic Dermatology tries to do the opposite: “Use the experiment as the basis for a new way of understanding the skin.” It is this conflict that, in my view, reflects not a struggle between the author and the reviewers, but a difference between two scientific positions.

Remark 9. Practical significance

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 9; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: Review No. 3. Undoubtedly, a huge amount of work has been done. Undoubtedly, it is interesting. At all times, scientists have sought to study the subject or phenomenon under investigation in as much detail as possible: they dissected it, examined it and broke it down into its components. In this respect, the cytoimmunogram, which shows the quantitative spectrum of cells, is of scientific interest. But how much is it of interest for the practice of a dermatologist?

The author’s response. From the very first lines, the author of review No. 3 writes: “Undoubtedly, a huge amount of work has been done. Undoubtedly, it is interesting.” This is a different tone. The reviewer is not trying to destroy the work. The reviewer is trying to understand: “Fine. But how can this be used?”

And this is a fundamentally different conversation. I would even put it this way:

  • review No. 1 is a defensive reaction of the system;
  • review No. 2 is academic criticism of the structure of the work;
  • review No. 3 is criticism from a practicing researcher who genuinely tried to understand what I am doing.

“How much is it of interest for the practice of a dermatologist?” is one of the most important questions put to the theory.

Indeed, any new diagnostic technology goes through the path from a research tool to clinical application. When it appeared, flow cytometry of the skin was primarily a research method. However, the history of medicine shows that many technologies — from immunohistochemistry to genetic testing — started precisely with a research stage.

Therefore, the question is not whether the method is widely used today, but what new possibilities it opens up for the diagnosis and understanding of skin diseases tomorrow.

Remark 10. Invasiveness of biopsy

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 10; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: Biopsy is an invasive method, while medical practice is moving towards minimally invasive or non-invasive methods of treatment.

The author’s response. The second very strong question. And here, to be honest, the critic hit the mark. Because this is not a criticism of the theory. It is a criticism of a first-generation technology. The remark rightly reflects the limitations of the existing technology for obtaining material. At the time the method was developed, the study required obtaining a skin biopsy specimen. However, this limitation concerns the way the data are obtained, not the concept of phenotypic analysis itself. The history of medical technologies shows that initially invasive methods often become less traumatic as research tools develop. And this is especially interesting now, years later.

Because if one day the following appear:

  • microneedle sampling;
  • liquid skin biopsy;
  • analysis of extracellular vesicles;
  • optical phenotyping,

it will turn out that in 2024 the critic was arguing not with the theory but with the technology of its implementation in 2017.

Remark 11. Cell numbers and interactions

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 11; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: — The pathological process in the skin depends not so much on the number of cells with a particular phenotype as on their interaction with one another through the cytokines and other humoral factors they secrete.

The author’s response. The third very strong question. The critic writes roughly the following: “The number of cells does not yet explain the processes. Cytokines, receptors and regulatory mechanisms matter.” And this, in my view, is pure gold. Because today, in 2026, I would say that the critic did not refute Phenotypic Dermatology but suggested the direction of its next development, rightly pointing out that a quantitative assessment of cell subpopulations does not exhaust the full variety of processes occurring in the skin.

However, Phenotypic Dermatology has never regarded the phenotype as the end point of research. On the contrary, the phenotypic states of cells can serve as a starting point for the subsequent study of cytokine networks, intercellular interactions and the regulatory mechanisms of the tissue microenvironment. In other words, the critic demanded level 2, while at that time I had only managed to build level 1.

Remark 12. The cytoimmunogram and diagnosis

Scan of a review excerpt in Russian, remark 12; English translation follows

Translation of the excerpt: Page 28. It is completely unclear how a diagnosis can be made on the basis of a skin cytoimmunogram. On the basis of the clinical picture, it is clear.

The author’s response. A very interesting point in the review. And here, in my opinion, the critic quite by chance formulated one of the main questions to the theory. Phenotypic Dermatology does not imply abandoning clinical diagnosis. The skin cytoimmunogram does not replace the diagnosis but complements it with objective data on the state of the cellular microenvironment. Just as a blood test does not replace the clinical examination of a patient, phenotypic analysis does not replace the dermatologist but expands the dermatologist’s diagnostic capabilities.

The critic’s whole review can be reduced to one phrase: “I see the value of the method as a research tool, but I do not see its place in everyday practice.” And you know what? I believe that was an absolutely honest position for 2022.

I consider this review not an example of resistance but an example of constructive skepticism. Of all three reviews, it is this one that best shows that a serious critic does not reject a new idea but asks:

“Fine. But how will this work in the real world?”

And this is perhaps the most useful question that any new theory can receive.

Conclusion

An analysis of such remarks shows that the main tension arises not at the level of data, methods or results. It arises at the level of language and initial assumptions.

On the one hand, there is an established system of notions based on fixed classifications and traditional diagnostic approaches.

On the other hand, Phenotypic Dermatology proposes a different level of description — to consider the skin as a dynamic system of phenotypes subject to quantitative and functional assessment.

Under such conditions, criticism becomes not only a mechanism for testing a new idea but also an indicator of the boundaries of the current scientific model.

Therefore, I regard the remarks presented not as an obstacle but as an important part of the process of the theory’s formation.

Perhaps one of the signs of a truly new model is that it first raises doubts — because it offers a different way of understanding.

Source: the author’s blog “Dermatologiya: ot nablyudeniya k ponimaniyu” [Dermatology: from observation to understanding] (goltsovs.ru, in Russian), section “Criticism”. The translations of the review excerpts are ours.

Translated from the Russian original. The English translation is awaiting approval by the author.